Why some of us dream as spectators - and what it could say about ageing
Blog: The Brain Dialogues
Blog: The Brain Dialogues
Most of us think of dreams as immersive experiences. We run, talk, argue, or flee from danger in worlds conjured up entirely by our sleeping brains.聽 In the dominant theories of dreaming, this participation - our sense of being embodied and active within the dream world - is predominantly taken as essential. 聽But not all dreams play out this way. Sometimes, we dream not as participants but as bystanders, watching scenes unfold without taking part. These are known as observer dreams, and they may hold untapped clues about how our minds change with age.
Observer dreams are characterised by the dreamer鈥檚 lack of involvement in dream events. In these types of dreams, you might watch the dream like a movie, with no sense of having a body, or drift through a dream world invisibly, like a floating camera but without engaging in the action.
What makes these dreams fascinating is that they鈥檙e not necessarily simpler or less vivid. They can be just as detailed and emotionally powerful as participatory dreams - the only difference is that you鈥檙e not in the action.
A growing body of research suggests that observer dreams are not rare anomalies but a consistent minority of all dream reports. Studies from the 1960s through to today estimate that at least one in ten adult REM dreams take the form of observer dreams. In a large Miami study of men in the 1960s, around 13% of dreams fit this category, with most involving a complete absence of self-representation.
One of the most intriguing findings is that observer dreams seem to occur more often at the edges of life: in childhood and in older age.
Young children often report dreams where they don鈥檛 take part at all. These tend to be simple and fragmented - more like snapshots than stories. As children grow, their dreams become richer and more participatory.
But later in life, the pattern seems to resurface. Older adults report more observer dreams than younger adults. Yet unlike children鈥檚 dreams, these aren鈥檛 simple fragments. They鈥檙e fully formed stories - just without the dreamer stepping into the action.
This suggests that observer dreams in older age may reflect something deeper about how our sense of self, agency, or embodiment shifts across the lifespan.
Dreams are windows into how the brain works. If our role in dreams changes as we age, this could reveal subtle alterations in how the brain constructs our sense of self and agency.
Some scientists wonder whether the rise of observer dreams in older adults could be linked to cognitive ageing - the same processes that underlie changes in memory, attention, and even risk for conditions like dementia.
Even more provocatively, observer dreams challenge the idea that dreaming is all about practice. One influential theory suggests we dream to rehearse life鈥檚 challenges - particularly threats - so we鈥檙e better prepared when awake. But if you鈥檙e simply watching danger unfold, unable to act, what鈥檚 being rehearsed?
Despite decades of dream research, observer dreams have been largely overlooked. Most studies focus on young adults, leaving huge gaps in our understanding of how dream experience evolves across life.
If observer dreams do become more common in older age, they could serve as subtle markers of how the ageing brain represents the self. They may even one day help researchers detect early cognitive changes before they become visible in waking life.
At the very least, they remind us that dreaming is not a one-size-fits-all experience. Our minds are capable of crafting entire worlds in which we don鈥檛 exist, or exist merely as invisible witnesses, rather than active participants.
Dreams fascinate us because they blur the boundaries between self and world, between the possible and the impossible. Observer dreams push this further. What does it mean when our brains generate vivid, meaningful stories in which we play no role?
For older adults in particular, this might be more than a curiosity. It could be a clue. As scientists continue to study dreams across the lifespan observer dream experiences may prove to be powerful indicators of how the mind adapts - and sometimes falters - with age.
Most nights, our dreams put us at the centre of the story. But sometimes, we鈥檙e pushed to the sidelines, left to watch from a distance.
Observer dreams may be passive experiences for the dreamer, but they鈥檙e actively raising big questions about consciousness, selfhood, and ageing. They remind us that even in sleep, our brains are telling stories鈥攁nd sometimes, those stories reveal more than we realise about who we are, and who we are becoming.
Research Published in Journal of Sleep Research: